The highest rated auto repair shops across New York, aggregated from every TopRated city directory in the state.
A good shop tells you what needs fixing now versus later, shows you the old part, and quotes before the work starts. The best build a relationship, not a one-time upsell.
Looking for auto repair shops near me in New York? Start from the city directory closest to you: New York City, Buffalo. Each one ranks the local companies and shows the service area, which matters more on this kind of work than a statewide average.
Based on Google ratings and review volume as of September 2026, the top rated auto repair shops in New York are SAL Auto Repair Inc & Kudos Rental LLC, Amherst Automotive LLC, L & B Auto Repair. See the live ranked list, ratings, and contact details on this page.
Every company ranked on this page serves New York and the surrounding area, including New York City, Buffalo. Open any listing for its address, phone number and service area, then call the two or three closest to you. Distance is worth checking yourself: the nearest auto repair shop is not automatically the best one, so this page ranks on rating and review volume first and leaves proximity to you.
A good shop tells you what needs fixing now versus later, shows you the old part, and quotes before the work starts. The best build a relationship, not a one-time upsell.
Run a business in auto repair & mechanics? After Hours AI answers your calls 24/7 so you never miss a customer.
Founding listings are free. We verify every business before it appears, so early businesses get the spotlight - your reviews, your services, and a direct line to customers searching in New York right now.
Claim your free listingPrefer to talk? Call or text the Top Rated directory on (813) 454-0813. This is our number, not the number of any business listed here.